employment law

Social media policies are a necessity for large companies – Fair Work Australia

Home → Case studies → Social media policies are a necessity for large companies – Fair Work Australia

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

3–4 minutes

The case of Stutsel v Linfox Australia Pty Limited [2011] FWA 8444 demonstrates the need for organisations to have a social media policy to clarify boundaries of acceptable and unacceptable conduct online.

Background

Mr Stutsel (Applicant) had been employed by Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Company) as a truck driver for over twenty-two (22) years and had an excellent work history.  His employment was terminated for serious misconduct because of a number of disparaging comments on his Facebook page about two (2) particular managers.  The Company argued that the dismissal was justified because of the following comments on Stutsel’s unrestricted Facebook page:

(a) a number of statements about one (1) of his managers that amounted to racially derogatory remarks;
(b) statements about one (1) of his managers that amounted to sexual discrimination and harassment; and
(c) two (2) extremely derogatory statements about two (2) separate managers.

As a result his dismissal, he applied to Fair Work Australia for unfair dismissal pursuant to section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act).

Submissions by the Applicant

During the arbitration proceedings, the Applicant gave sworn evidence and submitted a witness statement which stated, among other things, that:

  • his wife and his daughter had set up his Facebook account;
  • he thought that Facebook was a place where he could privately interact with a group of people who he had accepted as Facebook ‘friends’;
  • he was told by his wife and his daughter that they set up his account with full privacy restrictions and that to his knowledge, nothing he said or did could be seen by anyone but the people he had invited to be his Facebook ‘friends’;
  • he was not sure how one (1) of his managers was able to access his Facebook account as he did not, nor did his wife or his daughter change his privacy settings; and
  • he was not aware of any Company policy regarding Facebook, other than a general direction that it should not be accessed during work time (as opposed to breaks).

Submissions by the Company

The submissions made on behalf of the Company argued that the derogatory comments breached:

(a) the implied terms of the Applicant’s contract of employment, which provided that he:

  • act with good faith and fidelity;
  • had breached the required obligation of trust and confidence;
  • promote his employer’s business interests; and
  • not take any action that would damage his employer;

(b) the Company’s Workplace Diversity policy; and

(c) clause 6.1 of the Equal Opportunity and Diversity statement contained in the Linfox Red Book Induction, which was provided at the Company’s induction program, which the Applicant had participated in.

Decision

Commissioner Roberts concluded and found that:

  • at the time of the Applicant’s dismissal, the Company did not have any policy relating to the use of social media by its employees;
  • even by the time of the hearing, it still did not have such a policy;
  • the Company relied on its induction training and relevant handbook to ground its action against the Applicant; and
  • in the current electronic age, this was not sufficient, as many large companies have published detailed social media policies and have taken pains to acquaint their employees with those policies.  Whereas, the Company did not.

Consequently, it was held that:

  • there was no valid reason for the termination, as the Applicant was not guilty of serious misconduct; and
  • the termination of the Applicant’s employment by the Company was harsh, unjust and unreasonable.

Therefore the Company was ordered to:

  • reinstate the Applicant to his former position, with full continuity of employment; and
  • compensate the Applicant.

This case should be a reminder to all employers that social media policies should not be seen as luxuries but as necessities.  Comprehensive social media policies not only set guidelines for the online conduct of employees during and after work hours but they may protect an employer against unfair dismissal claims.

Further information

Dundas Lawyers has advised various organisations on issues associated with social media law.  To ascertain how Dundas Lawyers can assist you in implementing a social media policy, contact us for a confidential and obligation-free discussion:


Related insights about technology law

  • Albanese proposes new AI regulator and mandatory standards

    Albanese proposes new AI regulator and mandatory standards

    On 10 November 2026, the Federal Government published a media statement detailing plans for a new “AI safety regulator” and mandatory obligations for AI developers under proposed Australian AI Standards legislation

    Read more …

  • Telegram terror content: eSafety alleges Online Safety Act breach

    Telegram terror content: eSafety alleges Online Safety Act breach

    Australia’s eSafety Commissioner has commenced civil penalty proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia (Court) against Emirati-based Telegram FZ-LLC (Trade License Number 94349) (Telegram), alleging that it failed to comply with obligations to detect, deter and disrupt the distribution of pro-terror material and remove unlawful material from its messaging service. The proceedings, eSafety Commissioner v…

    Read more …

  • Privacy Amendment Bill 2026 proposes Privacy Act amendments

    Privacy Amendment Bill 2026 proposes Privacy Act amendments

    On 31 August 2026, the Australian Government published a Consultation Paper and released an exposure draft of the Privacy Amendment (Personal Data Protection) Bill 2026 (Bill), proposing amendments to the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) (Privacy Act).  The Bill proposes amendments to the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs) codified in Schedule 1 of the Privacy Act. The…

    Read more …

  • Digital Duty of Care Bill 2026

    Digital Duty of Care Bill 2026

    The Australian Labor party has introduced an exposure draft of the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 (Digital Duty of Care Bill/Draft Bill) for “consultation”.  The Digital Duty of Care Bill proposes to make a number of minor (and major) amendments to the Online Safety Act 2021(Cth) (Online Safety Act) and adds…

    Read more …

  • AI compliance programs: one size does not fit all

    AI compliance programs: one size does not fit all

    Australia does not have any standalone legislation addressing how businesses can safely implement Artificial Intelligence (AI).  Use of AI by Australian businesses is, however, regulated, not by a patchwork combination of Federal and State legislation, industry-specific legislation and standards, professional body rules and guidance issued by government departments and other regulators.  This article discusses the…

    Read more …

  • AI evidence misleading Court:  Ba v Sterling Parts Australia

    AI evidence misleading Court: Ba v Sterling Parts Australia

    On 17 June 2026, Symons J delivered judgment in the case of Ba v Sterling Parts Australia Pty Ltd [2026] FedCFamC2G 1245 (Ba v Sterling Parts).  Ba v Sterling Parts was a proceeding brought by Weiman Ba (Applicant) in the second division of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Court).  Symons J dismissed…

    Read more …

  • Office of AI announced by Federal Government

    Office of AI announced by Federal Government

    On 15 July 2026, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (Prime Minister) announced by media release an expansion of the Federal Government’s (Government) existing artificial intelligence (AI) governance framework, including the establishment of a new Office of AI as well as plans to legislate national standards governing large-scale data centres, AI training and the use of Australian…

    Read more …

  • AI businesses should have duty of care

    AI businesses should have duty of care

    In a recent interview with InnovationAus.com, Victorian Senator Michelle Ananda-Rajah (Senator) emphasised the need to adopt digital duty of care laws for artificial intelligence (AI) companies.[1]  As a representative of the ALP and former AI start-up founder, the Senator calls for the proposed digital duty of care to apply to AI companies.  If implemented, the…

    Read more …

  • Federal Court orders winding up of crypto mining investment scheme

    Federal Court orders winding up of crypto mining investment scheme

    The Federal Court of Australia delivered judgment in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v NGS Crypto Pty Ltd (No 5) [2025] FCA 1611, on 18 December 2025 ordering the winding up of two (2) cryptocurrency related entities after finding that they operated an unlicensed financial services business and an unregistered managed investment scheme in contravention…

    Read more …

Send this to a friend