shareholder oppression

How is compensation assessed for a breach of directors’ duties?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

10–15 minutes

Quick summary of compensation for breach of directors’ duties

Under section 1317H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a court can order a director who breaches a statutory duty, such as acting in bad faith or misusing their position, to compensate the company for its loss, including profits made from the breach. Equity offers an account of profits or equitable compensation instead, but the company cannot recover twice.

Key insights

  • Section 1317H lets the Court order compensation where a director contravenes a civil penalty provision, including the duties in sections 180 to 183, and the company’s damage resulted from it.
  • Compensation can include profits made by anyone from the contravention, even if the company suffered no matching loss.
  • Equity separately offers a constructive trust, an account of profits or equitable compensation, and the statutory and equitable remedies can operate together.
  • The profits must result from the breach: in V-Flow, the Full Court reduced a $1,469,178 award to $788,710 for that reason.
  • A company usually has to elect between remedies, and cannot recover the same profit twice.

In V-Flow Pty Ltd v Holyoake Industries (Vic) Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 16 (V-Flow), a managing director and two senior employees secretly arranged to buy a competitor’s business for themselves. The trial judge ordered them and their new company to pay $1,469,178 in statutory compensation. On appeal, the Full Court cut that to $788,710, because most of the profits counted had come from running the business, not from the breaches, and left the company to choose between that sum and $1,046,923 for its lost opportunity.[1] This article explains how compensation is assessed when a director breaches their duties under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) and in equity. For an overview of how we help, see our corporate lawyers page.

When can the Court order a director to pay compensation?

When the director has contravened a civil penalty provision and the company’s damage resulted from that contravention.

Section 1317H allows the Court to order a person to compensate a corporation for damage it suffered if the person contravened a corporation/scheme civil penalty provision and the damage resulted from the contravention.[2] Those provisions include the core statutory duties: care and diligence, good faith and proper purpose, and not improperly using the director’s position or company information.[3]

A person involved in a director’s contravention also contravenes those duties, so a company knowingly concerned in the breach can be ordered to pay too.[4]

The decision to make a compensation order is discretionary.[5] The order must state the amount, can be enforced as a judgment, and may be sought by the company or by ASIC. Proceedings must be started within six years of the contravention.[6]

For the duties themselves, see our article on directors’ duties in Australia.

In short, section 1317H turns a breach of the statutory duties into a debt the director can be ordered to pay the company.

Can compensation include the director’s profits?

Yes. In assessing the company’s damage, the Court includes profits made by any person resulting from the contravention.

Section 1317H(2) says that, in determining the damage suffered, the Court is to “include profits made by any person resulting from the contravention”.[7] The Full Court in Grimaldi held that this is definitional: it empowers the Court to compensate for profits made from a contravention without proof of a corresponding loss to the company.[8]

It does not oblige the Court to sweep in every profit. In Grimaldi, each wrongdoer was ordered to pay only the profits that wrongdoer made, which the Court held was open in the exercise of its discretion.[9]

The Full Court in V-Flow described the language of section 1317H as “singularly inelegant”, noting that it conflates compensation for loss with an account of profits.[10]

In short, a director cannot escape a compensation order by showing the company lost nothing, if the director or someone else profited from the breach.

What remedies are available in equity?

A director who breaches their fiduciary duties can be ordered to hold property on constructive trust, to account for profits, or to pay equitable compensation.

Property

Constructive trust

Gains

Account of profits

Loss

Equitable compensation

No loss needed

An undisclosed profit belongs to the company

For whether those duties survive resignation, see our article on fiduciary duties owed by former directors.

In short, equity can reach the director’s gains even where the company has suffered no loss at all.

How was compensation assessed in V-Flow?

The Full Court held that only profits resulting from the contraventions could be counted, and that reasonable salaries and loan interest were proper expenses.

Holyoake’s managing director and two senior employees secretly pursued the purchase of a competitor, Variflow, while still working for Holyoake. They concealed their activities from management, and their new company, V-Flow, bought the business in April 2009. The managing director contravened section 181, and all three contravened sections 182 and 183.[15]

The trial judge assessed the profits for the account by taking V-Flow’s net profit for its first 27 months and adding back legal fees, consultants’ fees and interest, and adopted the same figure as compensation under section 1317H. Holyoake elected that remedy.[16]

RemedyTrial judgeFull Court
Account of profits$1,469,178$788,710
Compensation under section 1317H$1,469,178$788,710
Equitable compensation for lost opportunity$1,046,923$1,046,923 (unchanged)

On appeal, the Full Court held that V-Flow’s trading profits came from the work of its employees, not from the contraventions. The profit that did result from the contraventions was the capital gain: V-Flow paid $615,000 for a business worth more than $1.5 million.[17]

The Court also held that a reasonable salary for work that someone had to do in the business is an expense, as is interest actually paid on the purchase loan. That is different from an allowance for the wrongdoer’s skill, which can be refused where the fiduciary was dishonest.[18]

Adding V-Flow’s profits to Holyoake’s lost-opportunity damages would have double counted the profit. The Court fixed the account of profits and section 1317H compensation at $788,710, and Holyoake could elect between that and $1,046,923 for the lost opportunity.[19]

In short, the claimant must show how the profit flowed from the breach, and the figure is only as good as the accounting evidence behind it.

Can a company recover under the Act and in equity?

Yes. The statutory and equitable remedies can operate together, but the company cannot recover the same money twice.

The statutory duties operate in addition to, and not in derogation of, the general law.[20] The Full Court in Grimaldi held that a company can claim an account of profits in equity and profits under section 1317H against the same director, and that the remedies are cumulative, subject always to the rule against double recovery.[21]

Within equity, the company must normally elect between equitable compensation or damages, on the one hand, and an account of profits, on the other.[22]

An election can be split between respondents. In Native Extracts, in which Dundas Lawyers acted for the applicants, the Court found it would be appropriate to order either an account of profits of $3,105,682 against the company that used the confidential information or damages of $1,904,375 against the former director and his company, with the applicants to elect once the reasons were published.[23] A separate claim that the former director had breached section 183 by passing on details of an extraction machine failed, because he had not obtained that information as a director.[24]

Others who help a director breach their duties can also be liable. See our article on third parties and breaches of directors’ duties.

In short, plead every available remedy, quantify each one, and make the election once the numbers are known.

Has a director profited at your company’s expense? Dundas Lawyers acts for companies and shareholders recovering losses and profits from errant directors. Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Practical tips for recovering compensation from a director

1

Identify every duty

Check the statutory duties in sections 180 to 183 and the director’s fiduciary duties, and anyone involved in the breach.

2

Plead in the alternative

Claim compensation under section 1317H, an account of profits and equitable compensation, so each can be quantified.

3

Get the accounting evidence

Brief an expert to separate profits caused by the breach from ordinary trading profits, allowing for salaries and interest.

4

Watch the time limit

An application for a compensation order must be started within six years of the contravention.

See also our article on calculating an account of profits.

Frequently asked questions about compensation for breach of directors’ duties

Key takeaways about compensation for breach of directors’ duties

  • Section 1317H allows compensation where a director contravenes a civil penalty provision and the company’s damage resulted from it.
  • Compensation can include profits made from the contravention, without proof of a matching loss.
  • Equity offers a constructive trust, an account of profits or equitable compensation.
  • In V-Flow, only profits caused by the breach counted, and reasonable salaries and interest were deducted.
  • Statutory and equitable remedies are cumulative, but there is no double recovery and an election is usually required.

Need advice about recovering compensation from a director? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to claims for breach of directors’ duties

Dundas Lawyers acts for companies, shareholders and directors in claims arising from breaches of directors’ duties. We identify each statutory and fiduciary breach, plead the full range of remedies, and work with forensic accountants so the Court can quantify the loss and the profits, and our client can make an informed election.


Further reading

For further reading on directors’ duties and remedies, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Links and further references

Legislation

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 180, 181, 182, 183, 185, 1317E, 1317H, 1317J, 1317K

Cases

Dart Industries Inc v Décor Corporation Pty Ltd (1993) 179 CLR 101
Furs Ltd v Tomkies (1936) 54 CLR 583
Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) (2012) 200 FCR 296
John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1
Keech v Sandford (1726) Sel Cas Ch 61; 25 ER 223
Native Extracts Pty Ltd v Plant Extracts Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 106
O’Halloran v R T Thomas & Family Pty Ltd (1998) 45 NSWLR 262
V-Flow Pty Ltd v Holyoake Industries (Vic) Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 16
Warman International Ltd v Dwyer (1995) 182 CLR 544

Further information

If you need advice on compensation for breaches of directors’ duties, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

[1] V-Flow Pty Ltd v Holyoake Industries (Vic) Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 16, [1], [10]–[11], [67], [86] (‘V-Flow’).

[2] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1317E(3), 1317H(1).

[3] Ibid ss 180(1), 181(1), 182(1), 183(1).

[4] Ibid ss 181(2), 182(2), 183(2); V-Flow (n 1) [38].

[5] Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) (2012) 200 FCR 296, [627] (‘Grimaldi’).

[6] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1317H(1), (5), 1317J(1)–(2), 1317K.

[7] Ibid s 1317H(2).

[8] Grimaldi (n 5) [630]–[631]; V-Flow (n 1) [54].

[9] Grimaldi (n 5) [631], [635].

[10] V-Flow (n 1) [54].

[11] Grimaldi (n 5) [183], citing Keech v Sandford (1726) Sel Cas Ch 61; 25 ER 223 and John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1, [126]–[129].

[12] Grimaldi (n 5) [186]; V-Flow (n 1) [57], citing Dart Industries Inc v Décor Corporation Pty Ltd (1993) 179 CLR 101, 111.

[13] Grimaldi (n 5) [187], citing O’Halloran v R T Thomas & Family Pty Ltd (1998) 45 NSWLR 262, 272–9; V-Flow (n 1) [55]–[56].

[14] Furs Ltd v Tomkies (1936) 54 CLR 583, 592, quoted in Grimaldi (n 5) [185].

[15] V-Flow (n 1) [5]–[6], [22], [29]–[31].

[16] Ibid [10]–[11], [35], [38]–[39].

[17] Ibid [66]–[67].

[18] Ibid [69]–[71], [74].

[19] Ibid [82], [86].

[20] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 185.

[21] Grimaldi (n 5) [640]–[641], [648].

[22] V-Flow (n 1) [53].

[23] Native Extracts Pty Ltd v Plant Extracts Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 106, [197]–[198], [231], [295] (‘Native Extracts’).

[24] Ibid [105]–[106].

Related insights about directors’ duties


Posted

in

,
Send this to a friend