Quick summary of innocent infringement of copyright
Copyright infringement occurs regardless of whether it is intentional or not. Section 115(3) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) provides the special defence of innocent infringement, which requires both subjective and objective unawareness.
Key insights
- Under the Act, copyright infringement occurs regardless of whether it is intentional or not.
- Where the defence applies, the plaintiff is not entitled to any damages against the defendant, but is entitled to an account of profits.
- The defendant must establish an active subjective lack of awareness and that they had no reasonable grounds for suspecting that the act constituted an infringement.
- An incorrect belief that copyright could not subsist in a particular type of work is insufficient.
- A choice not to inquire may suggest a mind in which real suspicion resided.
On this page
- Quick summary
- What are the elements of the innocent infringement defence?
- What is the Subjective Unawareness Element?
- What is the Reasonable Suspicion Element?
- Can you rely on the innocent infringement defence?
- Practical tips
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
- Our approach
- Further reading
- Links and further references
Under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (Act), copyright infringement occurs regardless of whether it is intentional or not. Artistic works are particularly susceptible to copyright infringement, because it is possible for two individuals to separately come up with the same idea, reproduce it in a material form, publish it and communicate it to the public.
The result is that an infringer may think they are absolutely entitled to exploit what they consider to be their IP, despite allegations to the contrary. To deal with this situation, section 115(3) of the Act provides the special defence of "innocent infringement". For an overview of how we help, see our copyright protection page.
The section states:
"(3) Where, in an action for infringement of copyright, it is established that an infringement was committed but it is also established that, at the time of the infringement, the defendant was not aware, and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting, that the act constituting the infringement was an infringement of the copyright, the plaintiff is not entitled under this section to any damages against the defendant in respect of the infringement, but is entitled to an account of profits in respect of the infringement whether any other relief is granted under this section or not."
——— The elements
What are the elements of the innocent infringement defence?
The defendant must establish both a subjective lack of awareness and that they had no reasonable grounds for suspecting infringement.
Justices Lee, Von Doussa and Heerey held in Milwell Pty Ltd v Olympic Amusements Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 63 (Milwell) at [52] that to obtain the protection of section 115(3) the defendant must establish that at the time of the infringement:
- they had an active subjective lack of awareness that the act constituting the infringement was an infringement of the copyright (Subjective Unawareness Element); and
- they had objectively considered, they had no reasonable grounds for suspecting that the act constituted an infringement (Reasonable Suspicion Element).
| Element | What the defendant must establish | Case |
|---|---|---|
| Subjective Unawareness Element | They had an active subjective lack of awareness that the act constituting the infringement was an infringement of the copyright. | Milwell at [52]; Golden Editions at 480 |
| Reasonable Suspicion Element | They had objectively considered, they had no reasonable grounds for suspecting that the act constituted an infringement. | Milwell at [52]; Golden Editions at 488; Vawdrey |
In short, the defence requires both subjective and objective unawareness.
——— Subjective unawareness
What is the Subjective Unawareness Element?
The defendant must prove that they were in fact unaware that the act was an infringement of copyright generally, whoever owns it.
In Golden Editions Pty Ltd v Polygram Pty Ltd (1996) 61 FCR 479 (Golden Editions) Burchett and Tamberlin JJ held at 480 that for this element to be satisfied the defendant must prove that they were in fact unaware of the infringement. The question is not whether the defendant was unaware they were infringing the applicant's copyright, rather that they were unaware that it was an infringement of copyright generally, whoever owns it.
Furthermore, it was held in Milwell that an incorrect belief that copyright could not subsist in a particular type of work is insufficient. The defendant must present a positive case proving an 'active, subjective lack of awareness' that the act in question constituted infringement of copyright.
In short, an incorrect belief that copyright could not subsist in a particular type of work is insufficient.
Facing a claim of copyright infringement? Dundas Lawyers advises on copyright law and the innocent infringement defence. Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.
——— Reasonable suspicion
What is the Reasonable Suspicion Element?
A mistake of law is generally not sufficient, unless that mistake was made after reasonable enquiry and investigation.
A mistake of law is generally not sufficient to ground the special defence of innocent infringement, unless that mistake was made after reasonable enquiry and investigation. It was further held in Golden Editions at 488 that a choice not to inquire may suggest a mind in which real suspicion resided.
In the 2009 decision of Vawdrey Australia Pty Ltd v Kruger Transport Equipment Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 156, the appellant (Vawdrey) denied receiving any oral or written communications from the owner of the copyrighted material (a sliding gate solution). However, as questions had been raised as to the source of the design to be manufactured, Justices Moore and Bennett upheld the decision at first instance that the appellant had been put on notice. Therefore, Vawdrey could not rely on the innocent infringement defence, as reasonable concern for inquiry was warranted.
In short, a choice not to inquire may suggest a mind in which real suspicion resided.
——— Takeaways
Can you rely on the innocent infringement defence?
The innocent infringement defence is not a catch all provision for copyright infringers to hide behind.
The innocent infringement defence is not a catch all provision for copyright infringers to hide behind. The case law provides clear limits that require both subjective and objective unawareness. It is best to consult with a lawyer if you think that this special defence applies to your situation.
——— Practical tips
Practical tips on innocent infringement
Inquire when questions are raised
Where questions have been raised as to the source of a design, reasonable concern for inquiry may be warranted, as in Vawdrey.
Do not assume no copyright
An incorrect belief that copyright could not subsist in a particular type of work is insufficient.
Be ready to prove it
The defendant must present a positive case proving an 'active, subjective lack of awareness' that the act constituted infringement of copyright.
Get advice early
It is best to consult with a lawyer if you think that this special defence applies to your situation.
See also our article on how much copying leads to copyright infringement.
Frequently asked questions about innocent infringement of copyright
Does copyright infringement have to be intentional?
No. Under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), copyright infringement occurs regardless of whether it is intentional or not.
What is the innocent infringement defence?
Section 115(3) of the Act provides the special defence of innocent infringement where, at the time of the infringement, the defendant was not aware, and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting, that the act was an infringement of the copyright.
What happens if the defence succeeds?
The plaintiff is not entitled under section 115 to any damages against the defendant in respect of the infringement, but is entitled to an account of profits.
Is it enough that I did not know who owned the copyright?
The question is not whether the defendant was unaware they were infringing the applicant's copyright, rather that they were unaware that it was an infringement of copyright generally, whoever owns it.
Is a mistake of law a defence?
A mistake of law is generally not sufficient to ground the special defence of innocent infringement, unless that mistake was made after reasonable enquiry and investigation.
What if I chose not to inquire?
In Golden Editions it was held that a choice not to inquire may suggest a mind in which real suspicion resided.
Key takeaways on innocent infringement of copyright
- Copyright infringement occurs regardless of whether it is intentional or not.
- Section 115(3) of the Act provides the special defence of innocent infringement.
- The defendant must establish both the Subjective Unawareness Element and the Reasonable Suspicion Element.
- A mistake of law is generally not sufficient unless that mistake was made after reasonable enquiry and investigation.
- The innocent infringement defence is not a catch all provision for copyright infringers to hide behind.
Need advice on copyright infringement? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.
Our approach to innocent infringement claims
Dundas Lawyers advises on copyright law, including whether the innocent infringement defence applies. We look at what the defendant knew at the time of the infringement and whether there were reasonable grounds for suspecting infringement.
Further reading
For further reading on copyright infringement, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.
- Infringement – how much copying leads to copyright infringement. See: How much copying leads to copyright infringement?
- Accessory liability – when others are liable for copyright infringement. See: What is accessory liability for copyright infringement?
- Damages – user principle damages in copyright cases. See: "User principle" damages in copyright breach cases
- Copyright notices – how to use the © copyright symbol. See: How should you use the © copyright symbol in Australia?
- Moral rights – the moral rights of creators. See: What exactly are moral rights?
Links and further references
Legislation
Cases
Golden Editions Pty Ltd v Polygram Pty Ltd (1996) 61 FCR 379
Milwell Pty Ltd v Olympic Amusements Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 63
The Dempsey Group Pty Ltd v Spotlight Pty Ltd (No 3) [2019] FCA 519
Vawdrey Australia Pty Ltd v Kruger Transport Equipment Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 156
Further information about copyright infringement
If you need advice on copyright law contact us for a confidential and obligation free discussion.

Malcolm Burrows B.Bus.,MBA.,LL.B.,LL.M.,MQLS.
Legal Practice Director
T: +61 7 3221 0013 (preferred)
M: +61 419 726 535
E: mburrows@dundaslawyers.com.au

Disclaimer
This article contains general commentary only. You should not rely on the commentary as legal advice. Specific legal advice should be obtained to ascertain how the law applies to your particular circumstances.


