shareholder oppression

Can a director's misuse of company funds be shareholder oppression?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

10–15 minutes

Quick summary of misuse of funds as oppression

Yes.  Where a director is found to have breached their fiduciary duty because they have misappropriated funds or assets, this can be considered as being oppressive conduct under section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act).  An applicant is entitled to rely on the cumulative effect of a number of actions to constitute oppression.

Key insights

  • Where a director is found to have breached their fiduciary duty because they have misappropriated funds or assets, this can be considered as being oppressive conduct.
  • The test for oppression is an objective one and is contained in section 232 of the Corporations Act.
  • An applicant is entitled to rely on the cumulative effect of a number of actions to constitute oppression.
  • In Martin, each breach on its own was not sufficient to amount to oppression, but the cumulative effect was sufficient.
  • The cumulative effect of a director's actions over time may support a finding of oppression, especially if the matters involve financial misconduct.

Where a director is found to have breached their fiduciary duty because they have misappropriated funds or assets, this can be considered as being oppressive conduct.  This was the case in Martin v Australian Squash Club Pty Ltd (1996) 14 ACLC 452 (Martin) when an executive director misappropriated and misused company funds and assets and was held to have breached his fiduciary duties.  For an overview of how we help, see our shareholder oppression lawyers page.

What is shareholder oppression?

Conduct that is contrary to the interests of the members as a whole, or oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against, a member or members.

Shareholder oppression usually occurs when a majority shareholder(s) misuses their power to oppress the minority shareholder(s).  The test for "oppression" is an objective one and is contained in section 232 of the Corporations Act.

Section 232 of the Corporations Act sets out the grounds on which a Court may make an order under section 233 if the conduct of the company's affairs, an actual or proposed act or omission by or on behalf of a company or a resolution or proposed resolution is either:

  • contrary to the interests of the members as a whole; or
  • oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against, a member or members.

In short, the test for oppression is objective, and section 232 covers conduct contrary to the interests of the members as a whole or oppressive to a member or members.

Who can bring an oppression claim?

The persons listed in section 234 of the Corporations Act.

Section 234 of the Corporations Act lists the persons entitled to apply for relief from oppression:

  • a shareholder of the company;
  • a person who has been removed from the register of members because of a selective reduction;
  • a person who has ceased to be a member of the company if the application relates to the circumstances in which they ceased to be a member;
  • a person to whom a share in the company has been transmitted by will or by operation of law; or
  • a person whom ASIC thinks appropriate having regard to investigations it is conducting or has conducted into the company's affairs or matters connected with the company's affairs.

In short, current and some former shareholders, those who receive shares by will or operation of law, and persons ASIC thinks appropriate can apply.

What happened in Martin v Australian Squash Club?

An executive director misappropriated and misused company funds and assets and was held to have breached his fiduciary duties.

In Martin, it was found that an applicant is entitled to rely on the cumulative effect of a number of actions to constitute oppression.  In this case, the plaintiff sought relief primarily on the basis of oppression pursuant to section 260 of the Corporations Act, which has been replaced by sections 232 and 233.

The alleged acts of oppression were:

  • misuse of money and assets of the company;
  • failure to call general meetings and directors' meetings and/or to give notice of such meetings to the plaintiff;
  • failure to keep proper accounting and other records of the company;
  • failure to provide the plaintiff with access to the records of the company; and
  • other matters, such as a purported transfer of ten (10) shares between the second and third defendants and the appointment of the second defendant as manager.

These actions were mainly alleged against the second defendant, Mr Harte.  The plaintiff alleged that a number of transactions amounted to misuse or misappropriate use of company assets.  Although each breach on its own was not sufficient to amount to oppression, it was found that the cumulative effect was sufficient.

In short, the plaintiff relied on a series of acts by Mr Harte, and while no breach alone was enough, their cumulative effect was.

What breaches of fiduciary duty were found?

Dealings with a vehicle, hotel accommodation benefits and audio-visual equipment were each a breach of fiduciary duty.

On one occasion, it was alleged that too much was paid for a vehicle which was then used both for company purposes and Mr Harte's private purposes without proper disclosure.  As the transaction was a dealing on behalf of the company by Mr Harte, Hodgson J held that there was a clear breach of fiduciary duty.

Other examples of breaches of fiduciary duty involved hotel accommodation benefits offered to the company, which was used by Mr Harte for other than company purposes.  Furthermore, audio-visual equipment to be awarded as prizes at a squash tournament sponsored by the company was instead gifted to members of the company and kept at Mr Harte's home.  This was held to be another breach of fiduciary duty.

The table brings these breaches together.

ConductWhat happenedFinding
VehicleToo much was paid for a vehicle which was then used both for company purposes and Mr Harte's private purposes without proper disclosureHodgson J held that there was a clear breach of fiduciary duty
Hotel accommodationBenefits offered to the company were used by Mr Harte for other than company purposesA breach of fiduciary duty
Audio-visual equipmentPrizes for a squash tournament sponsored by the company were gifted to members of the company and kept at Mr Harte's homeHeld to be another breach of fiduciary duty

In short, Mr Harte used company money and benefits for his own purposes, and each dealing was a breach of fiduciary duty.

Concerned that a director is misusing company funds? Dundas Lawyers advises shareholders on initiating and defending shareholder oppression proceedings.  Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Can a number of acts together amount to oppression?

Yes.  Hodgson J reasoned that the Court could consider the cumulative effect of a number of acts or omissions.

In relation to oppression, it was raised as a defence that it was necessary to show on-going oppressive conduct.  In addition the oppressive conduct must have the character or unfairness or unjust detriment to the plaintiff, and the conduct must not be acquiesced in by the plaintiff.

The defendants referred to the cases of Spargos Mining NL v Fuller [1998] WASC 219 (Spargos), Morgan v 45 Flers Avenue Pty Ltd (1986) 10 ACLR 692 (Morgan) and John J Starr (Real Estate) Pty Ltd v Robert R Andrew (Australasia) Pty Ltd (1991) 6 ACSR 63 (John J Starr), respectively.

In this regard, Hodgson J reasoned that the Court could consider the cumulative effect of a number of acts or omissions.  In his judgment, it was said at [66] that:

"Mr Harte regularly and in breach of his fiduciary duty mixed his own affairs and that of the company. The breaches of fiduciary duty were not de minimis. He did not disclose his conduct, as he was required to do, to Mr Martin – nor, probably, to the other directors either. The records kept under his supervision are so inadequate that it is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to sort out the true position in relation to the company's finances. From mid-1994 onwards, he set about to make it difficult for Mr Martin and his advisers to have access to company records and to participate in a meeting which could consider the business of the company. In my opinion, these matters amount to oppression under both paragraphs of s260(2). The other directors were not active in this oppression, but, at least by their conduct in these proceedings, they have acquiesced in it."

The issue in this case was that no one instance was sufficient to result in a finding of oppression.  Instead, oppression required consideration of the combined or cumulative actions.

In short, no one instance was enough, but the combined or cumulative actions amounted to oppression.

What does Martin mean for shareholders?

Martin raises the issue that an individual act by an errant director may not be sufficient to amount to oppression.  However, the case illustrates that the cumulative effect of a director's actions over time may support a finding of oppression, especially if the matters involve financial misconduct.

In short, look at the whole of a director's conduct over time, especially where it involves financial misconduct.

Practical tips if a director is misusing company funds

1

Record every act

An individual act may not be sufficient, but the cumulative effect of a director's actions over time may support a finding of oppression.

2

Follow the money

In Martin, misuse of money and assets of the company, and the mixing of a director's own affairs with the company's, were central.

3

Ask for the records

Failure to keep proper records and to provide access to the records of the company were among the alleged acts of oppression.

4

Do not acquiesce

It was raised as a defence that the conduct must not be acquiesced in by the plaintiff.

See also our article on a course of conduct as shareholder oppression.

Frequently asked questions about misuse of funds and oppression

Key takeaways from Martin v Australian Squash Club

  • The test for oppression is objective, and section 232 covers conduct contrary to the interests of the members as a whole or oppressive to a member or members.
  • Section 234 lists the persons entitled to apply for relief from oppression.
  • In Martin, an executive director misappropriated and misused company funds and assets and was held to have breached his fiduciary duties.
  • Dealings with a vehicle, hotel accommodation benefits and audio-visual equipment were each a breach of fiduciary duty.
  • No one instance was sufficient, but the Court could consider the cumulative effect of a number of acts or omissions.
  • The cumulative effect of a director's actions over time may support a finding of oppression, especially if the matters involve financial misconduct.

Need advice about a director misusing company funds? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to oppression claims

Dundas Lawyers acts for minority and majority shareholders in oppression disputes.  We test the conduct against the cases early, identify the evidence that matters and focus on the remedy that will actually resolve the dispute.


Further reading

For further reading on shareholder oppression, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Links and further references

Legislation

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Cases

John J Starr (Real Estate) Pty Ltd v Robert R Andrew (Australasia) Pty Ltd (1991) 6 ACSR 63

Martin v Australian Squash Club Pty Ltd (1996) 14 ACLC 452

Morgan v 45 Flers Avenue Pty Ltd (1986) 10 ACLR 692

Spargos Mining NL v Fuller [1998] WASC 219

Further information

If you need assistance in initiating or defending legal proceedings for shareholder oppression, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

Related insights about shareholder oppression

Send this to a friend