patent law and commercialisation

How do you prove patent infringement in Australia?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

10–15 minutes

Quick summary of patent infringement

Under section 13 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), a patentee has the exclusive right to exploit the invention in Australia. A product or process infringes only if it takes every essential integer of at least one claim. If infringement is proved, the Court can grant an injunction and either damages or an account of profits.

Key insights

  • A patent gives the patentee the exclusive right to make, sell, hire, use, import or otherwise exploit the invention in Australia.
  • Infringement turns on the claims: there is no infringement unless every essential integer of a claim is taken.
  • Adding extra features does not avoid infringement, but leaving out or replacing an essential feature does.
  • The patentee chooses between damages and an account of profits; additional damages can be added for flagrant infringement.
  • Infringement proceedings have time limits, and threatening proceedings without justification can expose you to a claim.

In Doric Products Pty Ltd v Asia Pacific Trading (Aust) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 849 (Doric), the same window winder was found to infringe every asserted claim of one patent but none of the claims of a second patent, because it lacked a single feature that the second patent’s claims required.[1] That is how patent infringement works in Australia: it is decided claim by claim, feature by feature. This article explains the rights a patent gives the owner (patentee) under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (Patents Act), how infringement is proved and what remedies are available. For an overview of how we help, see our patent infringement lawyers page.

What rights does a patent give its owner?

The exclusive right, during the term of the patent, to exploit the invention and to authorise others to exploit it, throughout Australia.

The rights are personal property that can be assigned, and the patent has effect throughout the “patent area”.[2] The patent area is Australia, its continental shelf, the waters above the shelf and the airspace above Australia and the shelf.[3]

To “exploit” a product invention includes to make, hire, sell or otherwise dispose of the product, offer to do any of those things, use or import it, or keep it for the purpose of doing any of those things. For a method or process, it includes using the method or process, or doing any of those acts with a product resulting from its use.[3]

Supplying a product can also infringe, if the recipient’s use of it would infringe, for example where the product has only one reasonable use or is supplied with instructions to use it in an infringing way.[4] See our article on contributory liability for patent infringement.

In short, anyone who exploits the invention in Australia without the patentee’s authority risks infringing.

What must a patentee prove to establish infringement?

That the alleged infringer, without authority, exploited in Australia an invention that falls within at least one claim of the patent.

Proceedings can be brought by the patentee (the person entered in the Register as the grantee or owner of the patent) or by an exclusive licensee. If an exclusive licensee sues, the patentee must be joined as a party.[5]

In most cases, ownership, lack of authority and the place of the conduct are straightforward. The real contest is usually whether what the alleged infringer did falls within the claims.

As Burley J put it in Doric, “there will be no infringement unless the alleged infringer has taken all of the essential features of the claim”.[6]

Expect the validity of the patent to be challenged as well: a defendant to infringement proceedings may counter-claim for the patent to be revoked.[7]

In short, an infringement case is won or lost on the comparison between the claims and the alleged infringing product or process.

How does the Court read the claims of a patent?

By giving the claims a purposive, not purely literal, construction, through the eyes of a person skilled in the art.

A patent specification describes the invention, usually with drawings, and ends with one or more claims. Whether a patent has been infringed rests on the proper interpretation of each claim, because the claims define the scope of the invention.[8]

The construction of the specification is a question of law for the Court. The words are given the meaning a person skilled in the art would give them, in light of the common general knowledge before the priority date. The claims are read in the context of the whole specification, but the boundaries they set cannot be narrowed or widened with glosses drawn from other parts of it.[9]

The words of a claim are of the patentee’s own choosing, and they fix the boundaries of the monopoly. It is the patentee who determines the essential integers of the claim as drafted, and each integer added narrows the claim.[10]

For example, a claim for a hammer might require (1) a wooden shaft, (2) no longer than 30 centimetres, (3) with a metal head at one end, (4) the head having a flat striking surface. Each of those features is an integer of the claim.

In short, the claims, read as a skilled person would read them, are the measure of what the patent protects.

What is an essential integer, and what if one is missing?

A feature of the claim that the patentee has made essential; if the alleged infringement leaves out or replaces one, there is no infringement.

The essential features are identified in the context of the knowledge that existed at the time, because the patent is addressed to people skilled in the art.[11] It is rare for the Court to treat a feature set out in a claim as inessential, and there is no infringement if an essential integer is replaced by a mechanical equivalent.[12]

Small variations are treated differently. The “pith and marrow” principle applies where an inessential part or step is omitted or substituted, but there is no infringement if the variant has a material effect on the way the invention works.[13]

Adding features does not help an infringer. If all the essential integers are present, extra integers that are inessential or do not make a new working of the combination will not avoid infringement.[14]

In Doric, the window winder did not have a stop moveable by insertion and removal as one patent’s claims required, so it did not infringe that patent. It took every essential feature of the other patent’s claims, so it infringed that one.[15]

In short, the alleged infringement is checked against each integer of the claim, and one essential integer missing means no infringement of that claim.

What remedies are available for patent infringement?

An injunction and, at the patentee’s option, either damages or an account of profits, with additional damages in serious cases.

Injunction

Stopping the infringement

Damages

Compensating the loss

Account of profits

Taking the infringer’s profits

Additional damages

Deterring flagrant infringers

DamagesAccount of profits
What it measuresThe patentee’s loss caused by the infringementThe profits the infringer made from the infringement
Additional damagesCan be added under s 122(1A)Not available (s 122(1A) applies to an assessment of damages)
Innocent infringementCourt may refuse damagesCourt may refuse an account

A court may refuse damages or an account of profits if the defendant proves that, at the time, it was not aware and had no reason to believe that the patent existed. If patented products marked as patented in Australia were sold or used here to a substantial extent before the infringement, the defendant is taken to have been aware unless it proves otherwise. Either way, an injunction is still available.[18]

The Court can also order the inspection of things and premises.[19]

In short, the remedies available depend on the election the patentee makes and on what the infringer knew.

Think a competitor is copying your patented product or process? Dundas Lawyers works with your patent attorney to compare the claims with the competing product and advise on the strength of an infringement claim. Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Practical tips if you think your patent is being infringed

1

Compare integer by integer

Set out each integer of each claim and check whether the competing product or process has it, ideally with your patent attorney.

2

Check validity first

Expect a counter-claim for revocation, and test the patent against the prior art before you sue.

3

Take care with demands

An unjustified threat of infringement proceedings can lead to a declaration, an injunction and damages against you; merely notifying someone of a patent is not a threat.

4

Act within time

Proceedings must be started within three years of grant or six years of the infringing act, whichever ends later.

The rules on unjustified threats[20] and the time limits[21] are set by the Patents Act. If you need information from a suspected infringer before deciding whether to sue, see our article on preliminary discovery in patent proceedings.

Frequently asked questions about patent infringement

Key takeaways about patent infringement

  • A patent gives the exclusive right to exploit the invention throughout Australia.
  • The patentee or an exclusive licensee must show the conduct falls within at least one claim.
  • Claims are construed purposively, through the eyes of a person skilled in the art.
  • Every essential integer must be taken; one missing essential integer means no infringement of that claim.
  • Remedies are an injunction and either damages or an account of profits, with additional damages for flagrant cases.

Concerned your patent is being infringed? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to patent infringement disputes

Dundas Lawyers acts for patentees, exclusive licensees and businesses accused of infringement. We work alongside your patent attorney to map each claim against the product or process in issue, assess the risk of a validity challenge, and choose the remedy and strategy that best protects your commercial position.

For more on patent infringement, watch our short video:


Further reading

For further reading on patent infringement, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Further information

If you need assistance with any aspect of patent infringement, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

[1] Doric Products Pty Ltd v Asia Pacific Trading (Aust) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 849, [6], [125]–[126] (‘Doric’).

[2] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 13.

[3] Ibid sch 1 (definitions of ‘exploit’ and ‘patent area’).

[4] Ibid s 117.

[5] Ibid s 120(1)–(2), sch 1 (definition of ‘patentee’).

[6] Doric (n 1) [38], citing Fresenius Medical Care Australia Pty Ltd v Gambro Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 220, [49]–[50] (‘Fresenius’).

[7] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 121.

[8] Kinabalu Investments Pty Ltd v Barron & Rawson Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 314, [40].

[9] Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 90, [67].

[10] Fresenius (n 6) [45].

[11] Fresenius (n 6) [52], citing Catnic Components Ltd v Hill & Smith Ltd [1982] RPC 183.

[12] Fresenius (n 6) [87].

[13] Ibid [92].

[14] Ibid [70].

[15] Doric (n 1) [125]–[126].

[16] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 122(1).

[17] Ibid s 122(1A).

[18] Ibid s 123.

[19] Ibid s 122(2).

[20] Ibid ss 128–129, 131.

[21] Ibid s 120(4).

Related insights about patent infringement

Send this to a friend