patent law and commercialisation

Can you be sued for threatening patent infringement?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

9–13 minutes

Quick summary of unjustified patent threats

Under section 128 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), a person aggrieved by an unjustified threat of patent infringement proceedings can seek a declaration, an injunction and damages. A threat is unjustified unless the threatened conduct actually infringes a valid claim, and only loss caused by the threats themselves is recoverable.

Key insights

  • Threatening someone with patent infringement proceedings, by letter, advertisement or otherwise, can expose you to a claim if the threat is unjustified.
  • A threat is justified only if the threatened conduct infringes a claim that is not shown to be invalid.
  • Merely notifying someone that a patent exists is not a threat.
  • Damages are limited to loss caused by the threats, not loss caused by the dispute or the infringement proceedings.
  • In Mizzi v Morellini, the threats were unjustified but no damages were awarded because no loss was traced to them.

In Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini (No 3) [2017] FCA 870 (Mizzi), a patent owner’s threats against a rival sugar cane planter were held to be unjustified, its infringement claim failed and its patent was later revoked. Even so, the rival recovered no damages, because he could not show that any of his losses were caused by the threats.[1] This article explains when a threat of patent infringement proceedings is unjustified under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (Patents Act), what relief is available and what must be proved to recover damages. For an overview of how we help, see our patent infringement lawyers page.

What is an unjustified threat of patent infringement?

A threat to bring patent infringement proceedings, or similar proceedings, that the person making it cannot justify.

A threat can be made “by means of circulars, advertisements or otherwise”, and a person aggrieved by it can apply to the court for relief.[2] It does not matter whether the person making the threat owns, or has any interest in, the patent.[3]

In Mizzi, the threats were a notice and a trade journal article warning North Queensland cane farmers of the “infringement danger” of copying the patented planter, and a later conversation in which the patent owner accused a farmer who had used the rival planter of infringement and demanded a royalty.[4] In Australian Mud, three letters of demand from the patent owner’s lawyers were declared unjustifiable threats.[5]

The mere notification that a patent, or a patent application, exists is not a threat.[6]

In short, any communication that threatens infringement proceedings can be a threat, whether it goes to the alleged infringer or to its customers.

When is a threat of patent infringement justified?

When the person who made the threat proves that the threatened conduct infringed, or would infringe, a claim that is not shown to be invalid.

For a standard patent, the court may grant relief to the person threatened unless the person who made the threat satisfies the court of infringement of a claim that the applicant has not shown to be invalid.[7] For an innovation patent, threats made before the patent is certified are always unjustifiable, and threats about a certified innovation patent are judged the same way as for a standard patent.[8]

The person who made the threat can counter-claim for infringement, and the applicant can then seek revocation of the patent in the same proceeding.[9] So a threats claim usually becomes a full contest about infringement and validity.

In Mizzi, infringement was not proved and the threats claim was upheld at trial. The Full Court later ordered that the patent be revoked.[10]

In short, a threat is only as safe as the infringement case and the patent behind it.

What relief is available for unjustified threats?

A declaration that the threats are unjustifiable, an injunction to stop them, and damages, which can include an additional amount in serious cases.

Declaration

Clearing the air

Injunction

Stopping the threats

Damages

Compensating the loss

Additional damages

Deterring flagrant threats

A lawyer or registered patent attorney is not liable for an act done in a professional capacity on behalf of a client.[13] The client who instructs them to send the letter remains exposed.

In short, a successful threats claim can stop the threats and compensate the loss they caused.

What damages can be recovered for unjustified threats?

Only loss caused by the threats themselves, proved on the balance of probabilities.

The requirement that the damage be sustained “as a result of” the threats is fundamental to s 128. Damage is not assumed; it must be proved on the balance of probabilities.[14]

Loss caused by the infringement proceedings, rather than the threats, is not recoverable. Where threats are followed by proceedings, the court will look closely at whether the causal link between the threats and the damage is made out.[15]

Nor is loss caused by rumours or general knowledge of the dispute. As Lord Esher MR put it, the liability “must be for damage done by the threats – not damage done by anything else”.[16]

Recoverable loss can include the loss of negotiations that ended because of the threats.[17] Damages for injury to commercial reputation have been allowed under comparable provisions, but a commercial reputation must be built on a trading history and cannot be assumed.[18]

In short, the person threatened must trace each loss to the threats, not to the dispute.

Why do claims for damages for unjustified threats fail?

Usually because the person threatened cannot prove that the threats, rather than something else, caused the loss.

In Mizzi, there was evidence of industry interest in the rival planter, but the reluctance of potential manufacturers and customers dated from before the first threat, and there was no direct evidence that anybody declined to deal with the rival because of the threats.[19] There was also little evidence of how the rival would have exploited the product, and Dowsett J “reluctantly” dismissed the claim.[20]

In Australian Mud, the Full Court set aside an award of $1,506,859 because the primary judge’s reasoning had not tied the damage to the threats, and the evidence did not show that the tool was ready for commercial supply when the threats were made.[21]

Mizzi (2017)Australian Mud (2017)
The threatsTrade journal notice and article (2010); oral demand for a royalty (2011)Three letters of demand from the patent owner’s lawyers (2006–07)
Threats unjustified?YesYes
Damages claimedLost sales opportunities and reputationLost revenue from a core orientation tool
Why damages failedCustomer reluctance pre-dated the threats; no evidence of how the product would have been exploitedTool not shown to be ready for market; the damages theory lacked a foundation in the evidence
ResultCross-claim for damages dismissed$1,506,859 award set aside on appeal

In short, winning the declaration is the easy part; proving loss caused by the threats is where most claims fall down.

About to send a letter of demand, or received one? Dundas Lawyers advises patent owners on making demands safely, and businesses on responding to threats. Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Practical tips on patent threats

1

Check before you threaten

Confirm infringement claim by claim, and test the patent’s validity, before any letter, advertisement or warning goes out.

2

Notify, do not threaten

Telling the market that a patent exists is not a threat; warning that proceedings will follow can be.

3

Keep a dated record

If you are threatened, record every lost deal, cancelled order and customer response, with dates, from the day the threat arrives.

4

Separate the causes

Be ready to show which losses came from the threats, as distinct from the dispute, rumours or later infringement proceedings.

Before making any demand, see our article on how patent infringement is proved.

Frequently asked questions about unjustified patent threats

Key takeaways about unjustified patent threats

  • A threat of infringement proceedings, by any means, can found a claim by a person aggrieved.
  • A threat is justified only if the conduct infringes a claim not shown to be invalid.
  • Relief includes a declaration, an injunction, damages and, in serious cases, additional damages.
  • Only loss caused by the threats themselves, not by the dispute or the proceedings, is recoverable.
  • In Mizzi and Australian Mud, the threats were unjustified but the damages claims failed on causation.

Need advice before making or responding to a patent threat? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to patent threats

Dundas Lawyers advises patent owners before they make demands, so that any letter is backed by a considered view on infringement and validity. For businesses on the receiving end, we assess whether the threat can be justified and help gather the evidence needed to prove loss caused by it.


Further reading

For further reading on patent disputes, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Further information

If you need assistance regarding patent infringement and intellectual property disputes, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

[1] Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini (No 3) [2017] FCA 870, [1], [20]–[21] (‘Mizzi’).

[2] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 128(1).

[3] Ibid s 128(2).

[4] Mizzi (n 1) [7]–[9], [13].

[5] Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 44, [4], [8] (‘Australian Mud’).

[6] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 131.

[7] Ibid s 129.

[8] Ibid s 129A.

[9] Ibid s 130.

[10] Mizzi (n 1) [1].

[11] Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 128(1).

[12] Ibid s 128(1A).

[13] Ibid s 132.

[14] Australian Mud (n 5) [23].

[15] Ibid [25]–[27].

[16] Mizzi (n 1) [2], quoting Ungar v Sugg (1892) 9 RPC 114, 118.

[17] Mizzi (n 1) [4].

[18] Ibid [16]–[19].

[19] Mizzi (n 1) [11]–[12], [20].

[20] Ibid [14]–[15], [21].

[21] Australian Mud (n 5) [1], [14]–[15], [22].

Related insights about patent infringement

Send this to a friend