confidential information

Is supplier contact information on an employee’s phone confidential?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

9–13 minutes

Quick summary of New Aim v Leung

In New Aim v Leung, the Full Court held that supplier identity and contact details may be confidential even where they are stored on an employee's personal device or messaging application.  Confidentiality does not depend on where information is stored.

Key insights

  • Confidentiality does not depend on whether information is stored in a corporate database, in a personal device or within a messaging application.
  • The relevant inquiry is whether the information itself possesses the necessary quality of confidence, having regard to the effort expended to obtain it and its commercial value.
  • Supplier identity and contact information may constitute confidential information where significant effort and expense has been invested and it provides a commercial advantage.
  • Where the assessment of confidentiality is affected by error, conclusions under section 183 of the Corporations Act may also be affected.
  • The matter was remitted for retrial.

For the latest update on this case and the current position of Australian Courts regarding confidential information obligations, see the article "Contractual and equitable obligations of confidence" published by Dundas Lawyers on 1 September 2026.

On 10 May 2023, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Full Court) delivered its judgment in the case of New Aim Pty Ltd v Leung [2023] FCAFC 67 (New Aim v Leung), allowing an appeal concerning alleged misuse of confidential supplier information by a former senior employee.

The decision provides guidance on:

  • the identification and characterisation of confidential information;
  • the treatment of employee held contact information and personal device data; and
  • the relationship between breach equitable and contractual duty of confidence and section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act).

The Full Court held that the Trial Judge erred when determining whether supplier contact information was confidential and remitted the matter for retrial.

The Judgment is of relevance to businesses that invest significant time and resources in developing supplier networks, especially in import, wholesale, e-commerce, and manufacturing sectors.  For an overview of how we help, see our breach of confidential information page.

What was New Aim v Leung about?

New Aim alleged that a former senior employee disclosed its suppliers' identity and contact details to two competitors.

The proceeding arose from a dispute between:

  • New Aim Pty Ltd ACN 115 804 432 (New Aim), an Australian online retail business which sourced products from Chinese suppliers;
  • Mr Man Hung Leung (Leung), a former senior employee of New Aim;
  • Broers Group Pty Ltd ACN 647 179 271 (Broers); and
  • Sun Yee International Pty Ltd ACN 159 318 224 (Sun Yee).

New Aim alleged that Mr Leung:

  • disclosed the identity and contact details of New Aim's suppliers to Broers and Sun Yee who were both competitors;
  • used that information for the benefit of Broers and Sun Yee; and
  • thereby breached his equitable and contractual duties of confidence, and statutory duties pursuant to section 183 of the Corporations Act.

At first instance, New Aim's claims were dismissed by Anderson J in New Aim Pty Ltd v Leung [2022] FCA 722.  New Aim appealed.

What information was said to be confidential?

The identity and contact details of some of New Aim's suppliers, including contact details held in the former employee's personal WeChat account.

The alleged confidential information included:

  • the identity and contact details of some of New Aim's suppliers; and
  • the fact those suppliers had been identified as reliable manufacturers capable of supplying products suitable for the Australian market.

A central issue concerned suppliers' contact details recorded by the former employee in his personal WeChat account.  The primary judge treated:

  • supplier information held in New Aim's internal database; and
  • contact information held in the employee's personal messaging account WeChat

as materially different categories of information when assessing confidentiality.

What issues did the Full Court consider on appeal?

The Full Court considered four issues, set out below with what it found.

The Full Court considered whether the Primary Judge erred in:

  1. concluding that the relevant supplier information was not confidential;
  2. focusing on the location and storage of information rather than its commercial substance;
  3. dismissing breach of contract and statutory claims flowing from the confidentiality findings; and
  4. rejecting the entirety of the applicant's expert evidence.
Issue on appealWhat the Full Court found
Whether the supplier information was not confidentialThe Trial Judge erred when determining whether supplier contact information was confidential.
Focus on location and storageThe analysis placed undue emphasis on the location and form of the information.
Contract and statutory claimsThe Full Court set aside the dismissal of the breach of confidence, breach of contract and section 183 claims, and the matter was remitted for retrial.
Expert evidenceThe primary judge erred in rejecting the entirety of the applicant's expert evidence.

Concerned a former employee has taken your supplier list? Dundas Lawyers advises on breach of confidential information.  Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

How did the Full Court approach confidential information?

The Full Court looked at the substance and commercial value of the information, not where or how it was stored.

The Full Court held that the primary Judge erred in assessing whether the information had the necessary obligation of confidence.  In particular, the Court found that the analysis had:

  • placed undue emphasis on the location and form of the information; and
  • failed to properly consider the substance and commercial value of the supplier information.

The Court emphasised that confidentiality does not depend on whether information is stored:

  • in a corporate database;
  • in a personal device; or
  • within a messaging application.

The relevant inquiry is whether the information itself, including supplier identity and contact details, possesses the necessary quality of confidence having regard to all relevant circumstances, including the effort expended to obtain it and its commercial value.

By treating WeChat contact information as distinct from supplier information more broadly, the Primary Judge failed to address the essence of the applicant's case.

Consequences for contractual and statutory claims

Because the contractual and section 183 claims were dismissed because they depended on the findings regarding quality of confidential information those conclusions could not stand once error was established.

The Full Court therefore set aside the dismissal of:

  • breach of confidence claims;
  • breach of contract claims; and
  • claims based on section 183 of the Act.

The matter was remitted for retrial.

Expert evidence

The Full Court also found that the primary judge erred in rejecting the entirety of the applicant's expert evidence.

While concerns existed regarding the preparation of the expert report and the involvement of legal representatives, those concerns did not justify wholesale rejection of the evidence.  The concerns included:

  • transparency in expert instructions; and
  • maintaining the independence of expert witnesses.

Why does New Aim v Leung matter for businesses?

The decision provides important clarification for businesses seeking to protect confidential information which is held on employees' personal devices.

Confidential information and employee knowledge

The Judgment confirms that information may retain its confidential character even where:

  • it is stored on an employee's personal device or messaging application; or
  • aspects of the information may be known outside the organisation.

The relevant inquiry is not confined to the physical location or form of the information.  Rather, the Court emphasised the need to examine the commercial value, character, and context of the information in determining whether it possesses the necessary quality of confidentiality.

Supplier and contact information

The decision also reinforces that supplier identity and contact information may constitute confidential information where:

  • significant effort and expense has been invested in identifying reliable suppliers; and
  • the information provides a commercial advantage to the business.

This may be so even where contact details are held by employees in personal contact lists or external applications rather than within system owned or controlled by the employer databases.

Interaction with section 183 of the Corporations Act

The judgment highlights the close relationship between equitable confidentiality principles and the statutory prohibition on improper use of information under section 183 of the Act.

Where the assessment of whether information is confidential is affected by error, conclusions regarding whether information has been improperly used for the purposes of section 183 may also be affected.

Key takeaways for businesses

Businesses should:

1

Identify confidential information

clearly identify and classify confidential information, including supplier and customer data;

2

Protect lists on personal devices

implement contractual and policies to protect the use of such lists by employees if using their personal devices;

3

Address personal devices

address the use of personal devices and messaging platforms in employment arrangements; and

4

Use exit protocols

ensure appropriate exit protocols are implemented when employees depart.

See also our article on preventing ex-employees from using your client list.

Frequently asked questions about supplier information and confidentiality

Key takeaways on New Aim v Leung

  • Information may retain its confidential character even where it is stored on an employee's personal device or messaging application.
  • The Court emphasised the need to examine the commercial value, character, and context of the information.
  • Supplier identity and contact information may constitute confidential information.
  • The Full Court set aside the dismissal of the claims and remitted the matter for retrial.
  • Businesses should address the use of personal devices and messaging platforms in employment arrangements.

Need advice on confidential information? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to confidential information

Dundas Lawyers advises businesses on protecting confidential information, including supplier and customer data.  We look at the commercial value, character and context of the information, not just where it is stored.


Further reading

For further reading on confidential information, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Further information

If you need advice on information confidentiality within your business, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

Related insights

  • Contractual and equitable obligations of confidence

    Contractual and equitable obligations of confidence

    Quick summary of contractual and equitable obligations of confidence In New Aim Pty Ltd v Leung (No 4) [2026] FCAFC 49, the Full Court held that the Respondent breached his contractual obligations and section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by disclosing seventeen (17) suppliers' details to a competitor, and that the equitable breach…

    Read more …

  • Can source code be confidential information?

    Can source code be confidential information?

    In Australia, computer code can amount to confidential information as well as being subject to copyright protection. This article explains what Campaigntrack v Real Estate Tool Box [2021] FCA 809 decided, and the High Court appeal.

    Read more …

  • How can a company protect its intellectual property from ex-employees?

    How can a company protect its intellectual property from ex-employees?

    Contractual obligations ought to be the main mechanism through which a company protects its intellectual property from ex-employees. This article explains restraint of trade, intellectual property generation and return of confidential information clauses, and what makes a restraint of trade clause enforceable.

    Read more …

  • Use of confidential information – the springboard injunction

    Use of confidential information – the springboard injunction

    This article examines the UK decision of Forse & ors v Secarma Ltd & ors [2019] EWCA Civ 215, which discussed the legal concept of a springboard injunction, and its implications in Australia. The Court must consider similar principles to determine if an injunction should be granted.

    Read more …

  • Injunction sought for breach of confidence

    Injunction sought for breach of confidence

    Dundas Lawyers helped a corporate client protect their confidential information and copyright material from a former employee and contractor. Read the full article to learn how they used detailed work and a chronology to secure justice for their client.

    Read more …

  • Are fiduciary duties owed by former company directors?

    Are fiduciary duties owed by former company directors?

    A former director’s duties and responsibilities to their previous company may not end with their resignation. Find out how the Advanced Fuels Technology Pty Ltd v Blythe & Ors [2018] VSC 286 case explored this concept and what the Court had to say.

    Read more …

  • What exactly is the springboard doctrine?

    What exactly is the springboard doctrine?

    This article examines the ‘springboard’ doctrine which refers to the benefit that is derived because of misuse of confidential information by a defendant that enables them to ‘springboard’ a new product or service to market more rapidly than if they had used their own mind.

    Read more …

  • What is the difference between know-how and confidential information?

    What is the difference between know-how and confidential information?

    Employees may take their general skill, experience and know-how to a new job, but not their employer’s confidential information. This article explains how the courts draw the line, from Faccenda Chicken to the Full Federal Court’s 2026 decision in New Aim v Leung.

    Read more …

  • Compilations from the public domain – confidential or not?

    Compilations from the public domain – confidential or not?

    The Court of Appeal in Ezystay Systems Pty Ltd v Link 2 Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 180 had to re-examine the test for confidential information. It found that for information to be protected, it must have the necessary attributes of confidentiality and must be the product of skill and ingenuity of the human brain.

    Read more …

Send this to a friend