confidential information

Can source code be confidential information?

by

reviewed by

Malcolm Burrows

Reading Time:

9–13 minutes

Quick summary of source code as confidential information

Yes.  In Australia, computer code can amount to confidential information as well as being subject to copyright protection.  The equitable doctrine of breach of confidence is designed to protect confidential information that was provided by one party in circumstances importing an obligation to the other party.

Key insights

  • In Australia, computer code can amount to confidential information as well as being subject to copyright protection.
  • In some cases the two things overlap.
  • In Campaigntrack, the source code as a whole, the three individual PHP files, the Database Work, the Table Works and the PDFs constituted confidential information.
  • When determining what constitutes the substantial reproduction of source code, a Court will likely use a qualitative test of substantiality to consider the essential or material features of the work.
  • Businesses should identify exactly what confidential information is and how it was alleged to have been misused or reproduced.

In Australia, computer code can amount to confidential information as well as being subject to copyright protection.  The case of Campaigntrack Pty Ltd v Real Estate Tool Box Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 809 (19 July 2021) (Campaigntrack) shows the importance of businesses identifying exactly what confidential information is and how it was alleged to have been misused or reproduced.  For an overview of how we help, see our breach of confidence lawyers page.

What are the elements of a breach of confidence claim?

The information must have the necessary quality of confidence, must have been received in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence, and there must be an actual or threatened misuse.

In some cases the two things overlap as was the case in decision of the Court in Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2010) 265 ALR 281; [2010] FCAFC 21 (Optus).  Paragraph 39 of Optus showed that a cause of action for a breach of confidence must have the following four (4) elements:

  • it must have the necessary quality of confidence;
  • it must have been received by the respondent in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence; and
  • there must be an actual or threatened misuse of the information without the applicant's consent.[1]

In short, computer code can be both confidential information and subject to copyright, and a breach of confidence claim must show the elements in paragraph 39 of Optus.

What did Campaigntrack claim?

That the DreamDesk source code, the Database Tables and the DreamDesk Database were its confidential information, and that they were misused or copied.

Campaigntrack made the following two (2) confidential information claims:

"Campaigntrack alleged that Mr Semmens, Biggin & Scott, RETB, Mr Stoner and Ms Bartels misused confidential information, being the source code for DreamDesk as a whole or individual source code files: FASOC [106], [110], [113]. It was alleged that Mr Semmens used the information in the development of Toolbox and that each of the other respondents knew or ought to have known that the source code was confidential information of Campaigntrack and New Litho and that the information was used in the development and use of Toolbox: FASOC [107], [112]. The use of the information was alleged to be unauthorised."[2]

"Campaigntrack also alleged that the Database Tables and the DreamDesk Database were, and contained, Campaigntrack's confidential information: FASOC [115]. It was alleged that Mr Semmens copied at least part of the Database Tables and the DreamDesk Database and that he did so at the direction of Mr Meissner, knowing that the information was confidential information."[3]

In short, Campaigntrack alleged that the source code was misused in the development of Toolbox, and that Mr Semmens copied at least part of the Database Tables and the DreamDesk Database.

What did Thawley J find?

That Semmens had misused Campaigntrack's confidential information, but not that the remaining Respondents had authorised or had actual or constructive knowledge of the misuse.

Regarding the two (2) confidential information claims, Thawley J found that Semmens had misused Campaigntrack's confidential information when reproducing the whole or a substantial part of the copyright subsisting in the DreamDesk source code.  However, Thawley J was not satisfied that the remaining Respondents had authorised or had actual or constructive knowledge of the misuse of confidential information and copyright infringement.  This is evident when his Honour states the following:

"I accept that Mr Semmens misused confidential information to the extent the claims in copyright are made out against him. The source code as a whole, the three individual PHP files, the Database Work, the Table Works and the PDFs constituted confidential information."[4]

"Mr Semmens held a copy of the source code and other information in circumstances which imposed an obligation of confidence; it was clear to Mr Semmens (and would have been clear to a reasonable person in his position) that he was not free to deal with the information as his own."[5]

"I do not accept that any of the other respondents knew Mr Semmens misused confidential information or used Campaigntrack's confidential information in the development of Toolbox or that any of them misused Campaigntrack's confidential information."[6]

The table brings the findings together.

RespondentFinding of Thawley J
Mr SemmensMisused confidential information to the extent the claims in copyright are made out against him
The other respondentsNot accepted that any of them knew Mr Semmens misused confidential information, or that any of them misused Campaigntrack's confidential information

In short, Thawley J found that Mr Semmens misused confidential information, but not that any of the other respondents did.

Concerned that your source code has been misused? Dundas Lawyers advises businesses on breaches of copyright in source code and breach of confidential information.  Call 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

What did the High Court decide on appeal?

That the Federal Court had erred in finding that the real estate agency's indifference to Mr Semmens' activities constitutes authorisation of the copyright infringement.

On appeal to the High Court of Australia in 2023 Real Estate Tool Box Pty Ltd & Ors v Campaigntrack Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] HCA 38 (Real Estate Tool Box), it was found that the Federal Court had erred in finding that the real estate agency's indifference to Mr Semmens' activities constitutes authorisation of the copyright infringement.  While this decision may come as a relief to businesses that hold the intellectual property rights in source code created by third party developers, businesses must remain aware that a flagrant degree indifference will likely constitute the authorisation of an infringement.

In short, the real estate agency's indifference to Mr Semmens' activities did not constitute authorisation of the copyright infringement.

What does Campaigntrack mean for businesses?

Businesses should identify exactly what confidential information is and how it was alleged to have been misused or reproduced.

When determining what constitutes the "substantial reproduction" of source code, a Court will likely use a qualitative test of substantiality to consider the essential or material features of the work.  As identified in this case, the equitable doctrine of breach of confidence is designed to protect confidential information that was provided by one party in circumstances importing an obligation to the other party.  Such obligations include not disclosing the confidential information or using it for unauthorised purposes.

In short, the obligations protected by breach of confidence include not disclosing the confidential information or using it for unauthorised purposes.

Practical tips for protecting confidential information in source code

1

Identify the information

Identify exactly what the confidential information is, for example the source code as a whole or individual source code files.

2

Show how it was misused

Identify how the confidential information was alleged to have been misused or reproduced.

3

Make the obligation clear

The information must have been received in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence.

4

Act on misuse

There must be an actual or threatened misuse of the information without the applicant's consent.

See also our article on the legal test for whether software has been copied.

Frequently asked questions about source code and confidential information

Key takeaways from Campaigntrack v Real Estate Tool Box

  • A breach of confidence claim must show the elements set out in paragraph 39 of Optus.
  • Campaigntrack alleged misuse of its source code and copying of its Database Tables and DreamDesk Database.
  • Thawley J found that Mr Semmens misused confidential information, but not that any of the other respondents did.
  • The High Court found that the Federal Court had erred in finding that the real estate agency's indifference constituted authorisation of the copyright infringement.
  • Businesses should identify exactly what confidential information is and how it was alleged to have been misused or reproduced.

Need advice about confidential information in source code? Call Dundas Lawyers on 07 3221 0013 or submit an enquiry online.

Our approach to confidential information disputes

Dundas Lawyers advises businesses on protecting against breaches of copyright in source code and breach of confidential information.  We start by identifying exactly what the confidential information is and how it is alleged to have been misused or reproduced.


Further reading

For further reading on confidential information and copyright, see the following articles written by the team at Dundas Lawyers.

Further information

If your business needs advice to protect against breaches of copyright in source code or breach of confidential information, contact us for a confidential and obligation‑free discussion.

Doyles Recommended TMT Lawyer 2024

[1] Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2010) 265 ALR 281; [2010] FCAFC 21 [39].

[2] Campaigntrack Pty Ltd v Real Estate Tool Box Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 809 (19 July 2021) [307].

[3] Campaigntrack (n 2) [308].

[4] Campaigntrack (n 2) [314].

[5] Campaigntrack (n 2) [314].

[6] Campaigntrack (n 2) [316].


Related insights about confidential information and breach of confidence

Send this to a friend